Bernini's Last Years and Spain's Empire Under Philip II

Bernini's flaws, his failed Louvre visit and death, why Italy's greatness faded, then Spain's vast empire, its price rise, bankruptcies and the weight of the Church.

BerniniSpanish EmpirePhilip II

~9 min read · Updated Nov 20, 2026

More of Bernini's work

Cardinal Scipione Borghese rivaled Urban in paying Bernini and giving him commissions. For him Bernini made The Rape of Proserpina, a dream of male muscle and a study of the female form, then a David in the act of loosing his sling at Goliath, and an Apollo and Daphne, an extravagantly imaginative picture of young men and women. These statues, now in the Borghese Gallery, led critics to charge Bernini with a mannered style that leaned toward the excesses common on the theater stage. Two busts of the cardinal himself survive, showing good nature and a love of good food. Yet the lovely bust of Costanza Buonarelli in the National Museum in Florence is more interesting still: she was a woman in Bernini's circle, and, as his son tells it, he was so deeply in love with her that he turned her into stone.

In Bernini's work, more than in any other artist's, the faults of the Baroque are visible. He appealed too much to feeling, and did not tell theatrical effect from drama, prettiness from beauty, emotion from compassion, or bulk from grandeur. He also used in sculpture the strong facial expressions that normally belonged to painting, and his close attention to realistic detail sometimes weakened the psychological effect. He rarely gave the faces of his figures the calm that lends the sculptures of Pericles' Athens their timeless worth. But why must statues express calm? Why should movement, feeling and the passion of life not breathe into marble and bronze? In Baroque sculpture it is a merit, not a fault, that the figures seem to have been given feeling and made to speak. Bernini followed Horace's advice and showed what he felt: the smooth texture of a girl's skin, the agility and liveliness of youth, the griefs and labors of leaders, and the piety and rapture of saints.

The Louvre and the end

For fifty years Bernini was held to be the greatest architect of his age. In 1665 (the book prints 1605), when Colbert and Louis XIV decided to alter and enlarge the plan of the Louvre, they invited Bernini to come to Paris and take the task on. He accepted, but drew a plan which, if not very wise, was very fine, and did not suit French taste or the French purse. Perrault's more sober facade was preferred, and Bernini went back to Rome disappointed and heartbroken. In that year (the book says 1667) he made a most interesting self-portrait in chalk, now at Windsor Castle: the white curls fall back from his large head, his face is lined with labor, and his calm eyes have an uneasy, fearful look, as if he saw where the paths of human glory lead. Yet Bernini was not beaten. For thirteen more years he went on building and carving with strenuous effort, a man of 'keen mind, firm resolve and fierce temper'. When his lamp went out (28 November 1680), he had outlived the Italian Renaissance.

Why Italy faded

Milton, who visited Italy in 1638, reported that Italian scholars felt their country's greatness had died with the beginning of Spanish rule and the 'Catholic reformation'. Perhaps the subjection of Italy and the censorship there did harm thought and art, though in Spain, under an even stricter Inquisition, Cervantes, Calderon and Velazquez flourished. In fact it was a Portuguese sailor, not a Spanish general or a censor of books, who ended the Italian Renaissance. Vasco da Gama had found a sea road to India which, though long, cost less than the routes that had made Venice and Genoa rich.

Portuguese and Dutch merchants took the place of the Italians; the cloth of Flanders and England drove Florentine traders from the market; and the Protestant movement cut the stream of gold that had once flowed to Rome from Germany and England.

Even in decline Italy kept its brilliance. Art no longer matched the age of Raphael and Michelangelo, and political thought lacked Machiavelli's depth and boldness; but from Leo X to Sixtus V statesmanship not only did not decay but advanced; science progressed from Leonardo da Vinci to Galileo; philosophy from Pomponazzi to Bruno; musical drama from Poliziano to Monteverdi; and only in poetry, from Ariosto to Tasso, can a decline be argued. Meanwhile Italy, like a foster mother, sent her art and music, science and philosophy, poetry and prose over the Alps to France and Flanders, across the Channel to England, and by sea to Spain.

Spain's greatness and decline, 1556 to 1665

Life in Spain

Readers used to English historians easily forget that, both before and after the Armada sailed, Spain was the largest, richest and most extensive empire on earth, that it thought itself superior in literature to Elizabethan England, and in art more important than the Italy of its day. When Philip II took the throne (1556), the Spanish royal house ruled Spain, Roussillon, Franche-Comte, Ceuta, Oran, the Netherlands, the duchy of Milan, the kingdoms of Naples, Sicily and Sardinia, the Philippines, the West Indies, most of South America, part of North America and all of Central America. To these must be added Portugal and its possessions in Asia, Africa and Brazil, as well as the protectorates over Savoy, Parma and Tuscany, and the alliance with the Holy Roman emperors, then led by Philip's uncle Ferdinand I. Spain had an army of fifty thousand men, famous for courage and discipline and led by the best generals of the age. Its navy numbered a hundred and forty ships (the book's figures), and its yearly revenue was reckoned at ten times England's. A flood of gold and silver from America poured into Spain's ports. The Spanish court was the most splendid, and its nobles the proudest in the world. Spanish was spoken by millions outside Spain, and the educated classes of many countries learned it, as they would learn French in the eighteenth century. Spanish architecture adorned the cities of five continents.

At this time Spain had eight million people, and its farming was declining, for land was turned to pasture to raise sheep for wool. Around 1560 only fifty thousand textile workers labored in the workshops of Toledo. The demands of the colonies spurred Spain's industries, and Seville became one of the busiest ports in Europe. The colonies in turn sent shipments of gold and silver. The abundance of precious metals drove prices up dizzily: in Andalusia in the sixteenth century they rose five hundred percent. Wages at first scarcely kept up with the cost of living, and in the end fell far behind. Most industry was in the hands of the Moriscos, Moors who had outwardly accepted Christianity. Household work was usually done by slaves taken in Spanish raids on Africa or in wars with unbelievers. Ordinary Spaniards scorned work and, like philosophers, were content with little: to sleep in a hut, warm themselves in the sun, play the guitar and lament the faithlessness of beauties seemed better to them than sweating like captives or Moriscos. The expulsion of the Moriscos in 1609, together with the rise in prices, ruined Spanish industry.

The expulsion of the Jews in 1492 had already left a gap in Spanish trade and finance. The Genoese became the chief agents of Spain's foreign commerce. Since the Spanish state was in the hands of nobles skilled in politics and war rather than economics, the country's wealth rested on gold coming in from abroad. For a time the state grew richer while the people lived in poverty. But part of that wealth went to war, and part flowed into the purses of the foreign merchants who held Spain's trade, until the state, like the people, fell into poverty. Spain repeatedly (1557, 1575, 1596, 1607, 1627, 1647) refused to pay its debts, or forced its lenders to convert them into new loans. These financial crises pushed Spain into war against Henry II in 1559, against Henry IV in 1598 and against the Netherlands in 1609. In history one must look for the banker, not the woman.

In Spain the priests too must be held to account for events. Nowhere on earth did religion hold such sway over the people, and so over affairs of state. Spain not only refused the Reformation, it also refused the Renaissance, except for a brief moment under Erasmus's influence, and remained medieval and content with it. The poor took pride in the Church's wealth. Everyone, from the king, who was more Catholic than the pope, down to the bandits who never parted with their religious medals and were never seen without scapulars, was devout and pious.

Written & researched by Dr. Shahin Siami

Related Articles