Religion in service of the state
Despite his despotism, in a Europe almost wholly corrupt, Philip trained officials and nurtured judges who were comparatively capable and just.
Although this king saw the Church as the builder of morals and the guardian of the monarch, like Henry VIII and Elizabeth I of England he made religion in Spain subject to the state. He valued religious unity so highly as a pillar of government that he said: 'Better that I do not reign than that I be king of heretics.' Believing that the Moriscos, while accepting Catholicism, still practiced Muslim rites, he issued a decree (1567) forbidding Muslim ceremonies, the use of Arabic and the possession of Arabic books. The Moriscos rose in revolt (1568), took a wide region south of Granada, attacked Christians and priests, and sold women and children to Arabs of North Africa in return for powder and cannon.
After two years of bitter bloodshed the royal forces put down the rising. The Moriscos were driven out of the province of Granada and scattered among Christian communities in Castile; their children were placed in Christian homes and made to attend school, something never before seen in Europe. Philip, who was busy fighting the Ottoman Turks, suspected the Moriscos of Valencia and Catalonia of dealings with the enemy, but was so occupied that he left the last stage of this problem to his successor.
Lepanto
His father had left him the defense of Christendom against Islam as one of the main policies of the Habsburg house. In 1570 he joined Venice and the pope in a holy league to end Ottoman mastery of the Mediterranean. While Philip planned and the three allies gathered ships, Cyprus fell to the enemy. By summer 1571 they had assembled 208 ships, 50,000 sailors and 29,000 soldiers (the book's figures).
A cross was set at the head of each ship, the banners were blessed, hymns were sung together, and the young admiral cried to the fleet: 'Christ is your commander, and you fight for the cross.' On 16 September 1571 (the book's date; the battle is usually dated 7 October) the ships overcame the enemy and ended his mastery of the Mediterranean. Since Spain had supplied the most ships and soldiers, the glory of Lepanto went to Don John and the king; Philip drew near the height of his greatness, which he reached when he inherited Portugal (1580) and added that strategically important kingdom to his vast possessions.
The Netherlands, France and the Armada
The one matter left to him was the Netherlands. He had heard that Coligny, leader of the Protestants, had almost persuaded Charles IX of France (the book writes Charles II, which I have corrected) that France should join the rebels, and he was much alarmed. When news came that Charles IX had had the Protestants killed in the St Bartholomew's Day massacre, Philip rejoiced and held more firmly to his resolve against the Dutch. He then arranged the death of William the Silent (the book's claim), but tried to win the friendship of Henry of Navarre with money. Henry paid him no heed, and Philip gave money to the Guise family and the Catholic League and thought of making his daughter queen of France, so that France and Spain together might defeat the Dutch, set Mary Stuart on the English throne and end Protestantism everywhere. When Elizabeth sent aid to the Dutch (1585) and put Mary Stuart to death (1587), Philip, who for years had calmly and by policy endured English attacks on Spanish ships, coasts and stores, resolved on war, and to fit out the fleet he drove his government into bankruptcy.
All Spain approved, prayed for his victory and felt that the fate of those ships would change the history of Europe.
Philip bore this shameful defeat with outward calm, saying he had sent the ships to fight men, not the winds (the ships were largely lost in storms). Although he lived ten years more and kept up the fight, the event broke his spirit; and it took a century for Spain to admit the defeat. He could hardly believe that God, after thirty years of struggle for religion, had abandoned him. Even so, he may in the end have grasped the bitter truth: after impoverishing his people by heavy taxes, in everything except the accidental conquest of Portugal and the temporary repulse of the Turks (who had retaken Tunis and were slowly recovering strength), he had met failure. Henry IV was advancing toward victory in France; the Dutch were unreconcilably in revolt; the pope would not pay a penny toward the cost of Spain's ships; Protestantism in northern Europe was gaining ground; England was gaining mastery of the seas and soon of America and the East; and that wonderfully wicked woman Elizabeth still sat on her worm-eaten throne, having reigned longer than any ruler of her age.
The end
Loss, loneliness and illness brought low this king who had once been proud and fearless. His fourth wife had died in 1580; of the three children she bore only one survived, a mediocre youth who was to inherit the first vast empire on which the sun never set. The people still honored Philip despite his errors and defeats, and trusted that he had labored for a holy cause and had been no more unscrupulous in politics than his enemies; without blaming him they bore the misfortune brought by his economic and tax policy and his defeats. At the end of his life the last legacy of his father, gout, gripped his limbs and paralyzed him. One eye was damaged by cataract, and painful sores broke out on his skin. In June 1598 he was carried by litter to the Escorial and laid in his favorite room, so that from its window he could see the high altar of the church.
For fifty-three days he lay in suffering, and he bore it in the hope that God would test his faith, keeping that faith to the terrible end of his life. In those days he clasped and kissed a cross and prayed. Then, as the last good act of his life, he ordered some prisoners freed. He sent for his son and advised him always to be merciful and just, and reminded him to look at the humbling end of earthly power. His suffering ended on 13 September 1598.
Philip applied his efforts with an intelligence limited by his particular upbringing, not large enough for his empire or fitted to his many responsibilities. There is no sign that his faith was false. I only feel that, like the followers of other creeds of that age, he was bigoted and ruthless, and that his faith, while it darkened and embittered his nation's life, eased their hardships and fed his pride. But he was not the demon his enemies' pens drew. In his own view he was as just and generous as any ruler of that century (Henry IV excepted). He was faithful in married life, loved his family and was dearly loved by them, and if they opposed him, he kept his calm; he was brave in hardship and careful in business. Philip paid well the debt of his large and unhappy inheritance.
Philip III, 1598 to 1621
His heir, Philip III, was altogether unlike him. His father, seeing the son's laziness and lack of ambition, had complained: 'God, who has given me so many lands, has not given me a son to rule them.' Philip III, then barely twenty, was more pious than his father, and it was rumored he had not committed even a small sin. He was shy and obedient, wholly unfit to command, and so left the reins of government to Francisco Gomez de Sandoval y Rojas, Duke of Lerma.
The duke was a benevolent man, for he raised nearly all his relatives to profitable posts. But he did not forget himself, and in twenty years as chief minister he gathered a fortune that an angry public put at 44,000,000 ducats (a figure the book gives as rumor). He also set aside funds for the treasury and with them sent two fleets against England (1599 and 1601), but both were wrecked by bad winds. Lerma had sense enough to welcome the peaceful leanings of James I, and after nineteen years of war a peace treaty was signed between England and Spain (1604). The war against the Dutch dragged on and drained away the gold coming from America. Lerma did not know how to meet, from the revenues of his exhausted country, the needs of his hard-pressed generals and his own expenses; and knowing that refusing any longer to recognize Dutch independence would do no good, he agreed with the Dutch a truce of twelve years (1609).
His next step, like war, needed money. Lerma was from Valencia, where thirty thousand Morisco families lived. In his bigotry he disliked these farmers and craftsmen, who had grown rich by work and thrift among poor but proud Christians. He knew that these converted Muslims had not forgotten the bitter memory of Philip II's persecution, and he believed they had treasonable dealings with the Muslims of Africa, the Ottoman Turks and Henry IV of France, who hoped in due time to stir up risings in Spain. The Moriscos, it was said, failed in their duty to the country because they did not drink wine or eat much meat, so that almost all the taxes laid on these goods fell upon the Christians of Spain.