Don Carlos
Legend, literature and pity have made Philip's first son better known than the king himself. Carlos had a weak constitution and was prone to fevers, melancholy, rage and pride, yet he was lavish in giving and savagely bold. One day he teased his grandfather Charles V for having fled from Maurice of Saxony at Innsbruck (1552), saying, 'But I would never have fled!' Although at the preparations for the treaty of Cateau-Cambresis it was agreed that Elizabeth of France should marry Carlos, in the signing Philip, widowed by the death of Mary Tudor, took the princess for himself, to keep France from friendship with England and turn its attention to Spain. The next year (1560) the bride came to Madrid, and Carlos, seeing her modest beauty, may have been angered by the right his father had taken for himself; but nothing shows that any romance existed between him and the fourteen-year-old queen.
Plays about Don Carlos were written by Schiller, Alfieri, Otway, Marie-Joseph Chenier and Juan Perez de Montalban.
Though sick, Carlos was formally named heir. In 1561 he was sent to the University of Alcala. There he fell down a staircase, split his head and was seized by delirium. Vesalius, the famous physician, operated on his skull and saved his life. But the people believed the cure came from the bones of a holy Franciscan friar (dead a century before), which were said to have been taken from the grave and laid beside the prince. Philip stayed at Alcala through his son's long convalescence and spent most of his time at his bedside. Then Carlos was taken to Madrid, where he regained enough strength to join young nobles in street brawls against men and women. His outrages strengthened the suspicion that the fall had damaged his brain beyond repair.
Philip was troubled that Carlos sympathized with the Dutch rebels. When Alba was named commander in the Netherlands, Carlos protested that the post should have been his, forbade Alba to go, and when the duke persisted, rushed at him with a drawn sword. The prince apparently thought for some time of fleeing to the Netherlands and putting himself at the head of the rebels. Philip, against their own wishes, charged several ministers to watch his behavior. Carlos drew up plans of escape, sent men to raise money and gathered 150,000 ducats (the book's figure); then he ordered eight horses made ready for his flight (January 1568). He confided his purpose to Don John of Austria, who told the king. Philip feared that his son, escaping from Spain, might be used by Elizabeth of England and William the Silent as a rival to remove him from the throne, so he ordered the prince kept under strict guard and, when Carlos threatened to harm himself, took away his weapons and confined him in the royal palace in Madrid.
Up to here Philip's conduct can be defended. But now zeal deepened the tragedy. Suspecting his son of heresy, the king ordered that he be given no books except a prayer book and a few devotional texts. Carlos threw the books aside and gave up every religious observance. A priest warned him that the Inquisition might want to inquire into whether he was truly a Christian. His health gave way in confinement, and after making his last devotions and forgiving his father, he died at twenty-three (24 July 1568). Antonio Perez, Philip's exiled enemy, accused the king of poisoning Carlos. Most Europeans accepted the charge, but later inquiries showed it false. Britannica says that in the painful affair of the imprisonment and death of Don Carlos 'Philip acted honorably' (Britannica, vol. 17; see also Martin Hume, Spain, Its Greatness and Decay, and Davis, The Golden Age of Spain). Still, the harshness used in confining the youth counts among the dark marks in Philip's record.
Don John of Austria
His treatment of his half-brother Don John of Austria casts another shadow on his portrait. The young man, an illegitimate son of Charles V and Barbara Blomberg, apparently aroused Philip's admiration and also his jealousy. Even so, Philip raised him to princely rank and sent him against the corsairs of Algiers, and John did well. Philip then gave him command of land forces against the rebel Moriscos of Granada, and again John finished his task without mercy or delay. Then Philip, when John was twenty-four, sent him as admiral of the fleet in the 'last crusade' against the Ottoman Turks. John beat them at Lepanto and became the hero of Christendom. He felt himself fit to be a king, and when Philip appointed him governor of the Netherlands, he was hurt.
The affair of Antonio Perez
This silent king, whose pride would never let him submit his conduct to people's judgment or defend it, was heavily blamed in another sad affair. Philip had taken into the royal council an ordinary but clever and cultivated man named Antonio Perez, said to be the illegitimate son of his close friend Ruy Gomez, Prince of Eboli. When Gomez died (1573), Perez became the confidant, and perhaps the lover, of Ana de Mendoza, Princess of Eboli and a woman of intrigue. It was said that Philip himself had had a liaison with this beautiful one-eyed woman eleven years before, though history may have given the matter a romantic color. Perez set out to plot with her so that both might gain from access to state secrets. When Juan de Escobedo threatened to expose their suspicious talks, Perez convinced Philip that Escobedo was plotting, and the king allowed Perez to have Escobedo removed. Perez held this permission for six months and then acted on it, to Philip's astonishment and distress. The next year (1578), reading Don John's secret letters, Philip saw Escobedo's innocence, arrested Perez and confined the princess in her palace. Under pressure Perez confessed his guilt and agreed to return 12,000,000 maravedis to the treasury (a gold coin once current among the Muslims of Spain, taking its name from the Almoravids, a dynasty of Morocco and southern Spain). With his wife's help, however, he fled to Aragon, where the Inquisition, on Philip's advice, prosecuted him for heresy.
From there Perez fled to France, declared that his troubles came from the king's long-standing love for the Princess of Eboli, told the governments of France and England of Spain's military and financial weakness, and urged Essex to attack Spanish ships and coasts. After repeated vain attempts to win a pardon from Philip III, whom he appealed to for shelter, he died in Paris in 1611.
A king at his desk
Philip was right to follow his father's advice not to trust colleagues. Spain's nobles, like the French nobility, envied the king's power and did not shrink from plots against him. Philip too set them against one another. He received reports of their differing opinions and then made up his mind; and since he trusted none of his subordinates, he personally supervised the details of everything: papal policy, public affairs, local faults, bridges and roads, the dredging of rivers for navigation, the founding of libraries, and the reform and codification of Spanish law, and he ordered a geographical, historical and statistical survey of the country, of which fifteen unpublished volumes survive. But since he took on more than he could manage, he fell into delay and hesitation, and he said that if the solving of many problems is put off by firm decision, they lose urgency and importance. In some matters, such as the Netherlands, events turned against him while he was studying the details or avoiding them. In his royal 'cell' he wrote with his own hand every order needed by his agents around the world. In his view a king must have absolute power. So he cared little for provincial assemblies except that of Aragon, and he issued decrees, and even severe sentences, without public trial, justifying his absolutism by saying that only in this way could he protect the poor from the oppression of the rich.