Duty before youth
Philip hardly had a youth: at thirteen he was made governor of Milan, and at sixteen regent of Spain, an office that was not formally real. Charles chose counselors for him, described their characters and manners with great effect, advised him to set the counselors against one another, and asked him to keep all true power and all final decisions for himself; Philip followed this advice to the end of his life. In 1543 he married his cousin, Princess Maria of Portugal, but she died in 1445 (the book's date, evidently a misprint for 1545), soon after bearing an 'ill-starred' child, whom he named Don Carlos. The book then says Philip married Isabel de Osorio, a woman not of his rank, and had several children by her, though he stipulated in the marriage that none of them could claim the throne (a claim the book makes; other histories describe this as a connection, not a marriage). His father advised him to leave her, since the duty of Habsburg princes was to find allies, by marriage or by war, around their old enemy France.
So, to keep the Netherlands out of English meddling, Philip had to set aside his taste for beauty and marry Mary Tudor, Catholic queen of England, and give her children who would keep England among the Catholic lands. He crossed the Channel and married the simple, sickly, hopeful Mary, eleven years his elder, and tried hard to give her a child, but failed; he left England for the Netherlands and took the reins of government there.
His burdens grew each year. In 1554 he was named ruler of Naples and Sicily. In 1556 Charles abdicated and gave him the throne of Spain. For four years Philip ruled his scattered dominions from Brussels, trying to fit his Spanish dignity to the good humor of the Flemings and the money matters of the Dutch. He had no love of war, but his generals won at St Quentin and forced the French to sign the treaty of Cateau-Cambresis (the book prints 1552, though the treaty was signed in 1559). To win some friendship with France, Philip married Elizabeth of France, daughter of Henry II and Catherine de' Medici; and when affairs seemed settled, he left the Netherlands and sailed from Ghent to spend the rest of his life in Spain.
The Escorial
Philip moved the capital from Toledo to Madrid (1560). Soon, since he loved solitude and was uneasy in crowds, he commissioned Juan Bautista de Toledo and Juan de Herrera to build, about forty-three kilometers northwest of Madrid (the book's figure), a complex including a royal palace, an administrative center, a school, a seminary, a monastery, a church and a splendid tomb; for Philip had by now become as religious as politics allowed. At St Quentin his artillery had destroyed a church dedicated to St Lawrence. To atone for the insult and to give thanks for victory, he had vowed to dedicate a shrine in Spain to this saint, so he named all these vast buildings 'the Royal Seat of St Lawrence'. In time the name became Escorial, taken from a nearby town whose name comes from the word for the slag of iron mines. Since St Lawrence was said to have been martyred on an iron grid, Juan Bautista drew the plan of the site in the shape of a grid, and from side to side he built halls, so that the palace's inner space became sixteen courtyards.
Traveling by car from Madrid to this palace, one wonders how, in an age with no faster means of transport than the horse, Philip could govern his vast possessions from a retreat hidden among gloomy hills. Today the huge buildings are nearly deserted, with only a few monks in them. But at first, with a Renaissance front 224 meters long (the book's figure), with towers, slender conical spires and the great dome of its church, it was an awe-inspiring sign of Spain's power, adorned with austerity and with art. Here the king ruled half the Catholic world, and religion and the state had turned into an astonishing blend of politics and stone. Here he could live as he pleased, among priests, monks and holy objects rather than courtiers, hearing the bells for Mass several times a day. Here the pantheon took the bodies of Spain's kings and queens, the library became one of the richest in the world, and in its halls were gathered in time masterpieces by Raphael, Titian, Tintoretto, Veronese, El Greco and Velazquez. Here Pellegrino Tibaldi, Carducho and Zuccaro came from Italy to join Spanish artists such as Juan Fernandez Navarrete and Luis de Morales (the book also names a Luis de Carbajal), and painted frescoes on the walls and domes. The royal palace itself stayed simple, and the church, though in a heavy Doric style, had an altar for the Eucharist that glittered with agate, gold and jasper, with an ornate niche behind it. The hall for receiving nobles was vast and splendid, but Philip's own room was the plainest of all, with the simplicity of a hermit's cell. The palace was a sign of Philip's power, and the room a sign of his character and nature.
The man in the Escorial
Philip tried hard to live like a saint, but could not forget he was a king. He knew he was the greatest ruler on earth and felt that politically he must keep up his dignity; yet he dressed so plainly that foreigners who came to the Escorial to see him took him for a servant and let him guide them through the palace! The prominent chin that marked his Habsburg descent should have given him away, for in that family the chin served as a kind of weapon against the world. In 1559, before time and its troubles had hardened him, a Venetian ambassador said he 'always shows such gravity and humanity that no king can surpass him'. An English envoy said Philip was 'of good constitution, gentle nature and given to quiet'. No one saw him laugh in public; his bitter enemies claimed he smiled only once in his life, at news of the St Bartholomew's Day killings in France. But in private he enjoyed jokes and laughed aloud.
Philip collected books with taste and enthusiasm, but preferred art to literature; he could recognize Titian's good works and criticize El Greco's. He also loved music and played the guitar when alone. He had all the Spanish manners, but from shyness his behavior lacked grace and seemed harsh at ceremonies. Until gout, caused by overeating sweets, struck him, he had a well-proportioned frame. He was prone to illness from childhood, and if he lived to seventy, it was only because he was resolved to finish his duties. He held affairs of state to be sacred and attended to them daily for fifty years. He truly seemed to believe that God had chosen him to hold back the Protestant tide, and from this came his dreaded obstinacy and harshness.
Yet he was 'not naturally inclined to extreme measures'. Philip never forgot good or ill done to him (except, the book says, in Egmont's case). At times he was vengeful, more often forgiving, and he held giving alms to be his duty. In a corrupt age he was incorruptible; no bribe or gift could turn him from his devout pursuits. In political conduct he resembled his contemporaries. He hated war and never began one willingly; for almost a generation he endured England's insults and only then sent a fleet against it. More than any ruler of his time he could show an outward piety that was calculated; the book says he apparently took part in a plot against Elizabeth so as to be able to prevent Mary Stuart's execution (a claim the book makes without proof). His rule in Spain was despotic but just. He 'paid special attention to his subjects and tried, as far as he could, to prevent social injustice'.
What friends and enemies said
His personal conduct was better than that of other sixteenth-century kings. If we accept his enemies' words, in youth he was 'strikingly sensual', and 'his chief amusement was to go out at night in disguise to indulge in every kind of license'. Years later William the Silent, who led the Dutch rebels, accused the hermit of the Escorial of killing his son and poisoning his third wife. But this furious man cannot be a good historian. A bold and great historian, the Spanish Jesuit Mariana, passed a similarly hostile verdict: while granting Philip qualities such as 'generosity, resolution, vigilance and moderation in food and drink', he charged him with 'lust, cruelty, pride, treachery and other bad qualities'. A recent Dutch historian concludes: 'Philip II cannot be charged with debauchery, extravagance and wickedness. After returning to Spain he led, as far as we know, a strictly moral life', and he was a faithful husband and a loving father. When his third wife, Elizabeth of France, fell ill with smallpox (then a deadly disease), Philip hardly left her bedside, though his ministers begged him not to expose himself to the infection. After Elizabeth's death Philip made another political marriage, this time to one of the many Austrian princesses, named Anne (1570). Anne died in 1580, and from then on Philip turned his attention to raising his daughters. His letters to them are full of jest and love. In his last years, when cares and defeats surrounded him on every side, Isabel Clara became his closest companion and only comfort; in his will he calls her the light of his eyes. He took little joy in his sons.