The Chinese Rites Dispute and the Jesuit Republic of Paraguay

The quarrel over Chinese rites, then the Jesuit communities of Paraguay, their fall in the 1750s, and the missionaries who died in North America.

JesuitsParaguayChinese rites

~9 min read · Updated Nov 20, 2026

The quarrel over Chinese rites

The rest of this story, which went on into the eighteenth century, might amuse a philosophical historian. In China the Jesuits, busy in part with scientific matters, had lost their zeal for theological narrowness. When they came to know the Chinese classics, they were amazed at the interesting wisdom they found there. The respect the Chinese paid their ancestors seemed a considerable support of moral and social stability, and in the teaching of Confucius there was something that led to the worship of the man himself. But other missionaries complained to the Roman Inquisition (1645) that the Jesuits did not show enough respect for the cross and the doctrine of redemption, which might shock the Chinese, who do not believe that a god could be killed by men. They also said the Jesuits celebrated Mass in Chinese rather than Latin, allowed new converts to keep most of the rites of their native religion, and grew very rich as physicians, surgeons, merchants, money changers and advisers to generals and emperors. The Jesuits, for their part, were horrified by the actions of the Dominicans and Franciscans, who told the Chinese that Christianity was the only way of escape from eternal damnation and that the ancestors they worshipped were burning in hell. Innocent X ordered the Jesuits to stop offering meat and drink to the 'shades' of ancestors. Meanwhile the Jesuit priests sent to Europe accounts of Chinese life, religion and thought, which in the eighteenth century became one of the forces that shook the foundations of Christianity.

The Jesuit republic of Paraguay

In South America the Jesuit missionaries won the respect and trust of the natives by founding medical centers and schools and by their efforts to reduce the oppression of the Spaniards. They also wrote dictionaries and grammars, explored dangerous inland regions, and made a real contribution to geographic knowledge. They also sent to Europe the bark of a certain tree, quinine, which proved very effective in treating malaria, and in Paraguay they founded a communistic society.

Among the pampas and forests near the Uruguay river, and above dangerous falls that discouraged colonists, the Jesuits formed settlements of Indians, and with the permission of Philip III of Spain they barred all white men except the Jesuits and the colonial governor from entering. They claimed that the people there were childlike and gentle, 'two hundred thousand Indians in every way ready for the kingdom of God.' They learned the natives' language but did not teach them Spanish or Portuguese and kept them from mixing with the colonists. To bring them to Christianity they won them over with kindness, humanity and music. They also built music schools and trained bands that learned to play all the main European instruments and could perform nearly any kind of composition, even selections from Italian operas. In time the natives could sing in chorus, and it is said that among thousands of voices not a single wrong note was heard. Bands of musicians escorted the natives to and from their work and played for them while they labored in the shops and fields. Christian festivals were held with singing, dancing and athletic contests. Jesuit priests even composed comic plays and taught the natives how to act in them.

Economic and government affairs were wholly under Jesuit supervision. The natives showed a remarkable talent for imitating European products and could even make complicated clocks, fine lace and musical instruments. Work was compulsory, but young people were allowed to choose their trade and to spend part of their time on recreation and learning. The average working day was eight hours. The Jesuits set the hours of work, prayer and play. Part of the land was held by individuals, but the greater part belonged to the community. The product of communal labor went to the state. A portion was set aside for seed or lean years, and most of it was shared among twenty thousand families according to their needs. Perhaps a small part went to the upkeep of the hundred and fifty Jesuits who served as managers, overseers, doctors, teachers and priests. By a royal decree issued at the Jesuits' own request, they could not share in any economic profit, and from time to time they had to report to their provincial superior.

Justice was in the hands of native judges and police. Punishments were flogging, imprisonment or banishment; executions were not customary. Each settlement had its own hospital, school and church, and looked after the old and disabled. The Jesuit government was a kind of communism founded on religion: the natives received their food and also the security and peace of a limited cultural life, but in return they accepted Christianity and discipline.

One may ask where the Jesuits found this remarkable form of government. Perhaps they took part of it from More's Utopia (1516), part from the Gospels, and part from the rules of their own order, which was a small communist island in the vast sea of individualism. In any case the system suited the natives and was established without force, through religious belief, and it lasted a hundred and thirty years (from about 1620 to 1750). When the community was attacked from outside, its members defended themselves so fiercely that the attackers were amazed. Even skeptical French philosophers were impressed. D'Alembert wrote that the Jesuits had set up in Paraguay a kind of monarchy resting only on the power of faith and on the mild manner of their rule, and that having gained control of those regions they made the people under them happy. Voltaire called this experiment 'a triumph of humanity'.

The fall of the Paraguay settlements

The community failed because it could not isolate itself from other communities. Spanish merchants accused the Jesuits of engaging in trade, and Spanish colonists, shut out from a region rich in resources and manpower, envied them. Bands whose business was seizing natives to make them slaves kept raiding the Jesuit settlements. The priests and natives evacuated the most exposed parts. When the raiders pushed inland, the Jesuits obtained permission from the king of Spain to arm the natives with European weapons, and from then on they resisted. But the greatest danger to the settlement was the course of European politics and ideas. The Jesuits' constant political involvement in France, Spain and Portugal, together with the free-thought movement and opposition from the clergy, nearly led to the expulsion of the order from every country in the second half of the eighteenth century. The Marquis de Pombal, the powerful minister who ruled Portugal, was an especially fierce enemy of the Jesuits. In 1750 he drew up a treaty by which Portugal gave up the colony of Sacramento at the mouth of the Rio de la Plata in exchange for Spanish lands to the north, which included seven Jesuit settlements with thousands of Indians. It had been wrongly rumored that the lands contained gold and that the Jesuits were hoarding it. The Portuguese authorities ordered the priests and natives to leave the seven districts within thirty days. The Jesuits (except one) were willing to obey, but the Indians preferred to resist and held off the Portuguese attacks for five years. In 1755 the Portuguese brought up cannon and many natives were killed. The rest fled into the forests or surrendered. The Jesuit superiors then ordered their men to return to Spain, and the experiment that Muratori called 'the happiness of Christianity' came to an end.

Jesuit missions in North America

We know the story of the Jesuit missionaries in North America better, and mention it only to round out our account of their work. They entered Mexico in 1572 and suffered much in converting the natives and drawing them to Christianity, but the main burden of that work fell on the Franciscans and Dominicans. The Franciscans left beautiful mission centers and buildings for the poor, from Mexico up to the lovely city named for their founder (San Francisco, apparently named for St Francis of Assisi). Many Jesuits suffered hardship and were killed in their efforts to convert the Indians: Isaac Jogues was mutilated, enslaved and finally killed; Jean de Brebeuf, Gabriel Lalemant, Anthony Daniel and others of the order died violent deaths in 1648 and 1649. We may not agree with the principles these men tried to teach, but when we consider the cruelty and greed of the Christian colonists, whose business was the slave trade and who complained that the humane activities of the missionaries would stop the 'Indian-eaters' from serving civilization, we should look with respect on the humanity and sincerity of the Jesuits and regard it, however small and sad it was, as an obstacle in the colonists' way.

Written & researched by Dr. Shahin Siami

Related Articles