Gregory XIII, Sixtus V and the Obelisk of St Peter's

Gregory XIII's reforms, then Sixtus V: poor-born pope, harsh order in the Papal States, and the raising of the obelisk in St Peter's Square.

Sixtus VGregory XIIIVatican obelisk

~8 min read · Updated Nov 20, 2026

Gregory XIII and the failed land grab

Gregory XIII continued the reform of the Church at a calmer pace. He was the pope who corrected the calendar, and also the one who had a Mass of thanksgiving sung for the events of Saint Bartholomew's night in France. Yet he had moral merits: he was moderate, kindly by nature, generous in charity and tireless in administration. His appointments were praised even by Protestants. Montaigne, who saw him in 1580, found him 'a fine old man of medium height, with a dignified face and a long white beard', and wrote that he was calm and kept his composure in worldly affairs.

But his policies, such as helping the Jesuit schools, pursuing the French Protestants and deposing Elizabeth, cost money. To raise it Gregory ordered that the letter of the law be enforced on landowners and title deeds in the Papal States. Many estates that should have reverted to the pope for lack of heirs, and the lands of papal vassals who had failed to pay their debts, came into his hands. The real and future victims armed their followers, refused to hand over their land, and turned to banditry. Nobles such as Alfonso Piccolomini and Roberto Malatesta led rebels who seized towns and closed the roads to travelers. Taxes could no longer be collected, money stopped reaching Rome, and before long papal affairs fell into confusion. Gregory had to give up the seizures and make peace with Piccolomini, and he died in humiliating failure.

Sixtus V, from a hut to the papacy

Necessity makes men, and one such man was Felice Peretti, elected as Sixtus V (1585 to 1590), who counts among the greatest of the popes. He was born at Grottammare near Ancona in a wretched hut whose thatched roof was so badly daubed that light came through it, and later he joked that he had been born into an 'illustrious' family. After his early schooling in a Franciscan monastery at Montalto he studied at Bologna and Ferrara and took a doctorate in theology. His eloquent sermons and administrative ability brought him quick advancement, and he was elected pope at sixty-four because the college of cardinals judged him a man of will, useful for restoring calm and reforming the Papal States.

His greedy relatives gathered around him and he could not resist them, so favoritism toward kin spread. But where his relatives were not concerned the pope was grave and unbending. His looks were not impressive: short and broad, strong, with a large forehead, a wide white beard, big nose and ears, heavy brows, and piercing eyes that could silence opponents without a word. His ruddy complexion matched his hot temper, and his large head showed an unchangeable will. For all his severity he was witty and sharp. Once he predicted that Henry IV would defeat the duke of Mayenne, because Henry spent less time in bed than Mayenne, and Mayenne spent more time at table than Henry. Sixtus himself slept little and worked long.

The war on bandits

First he set out to suppress the successful brigands, reviving a forgotten law that forbade carrying deadly weapons. The day before he took office, four young men were arrested for breaking it. Sixtus ordered them hanged. Their relatives asked for pardon and delay, but he answered, 'As long as I live, every criminal must die.' Some time later, amid the festivities of his coronation, the sentence was carried out near the bridge of Sant'Angelo. This was his inaugural speech and his declaration of policy toward crime.

Then the pope ordered the nobles to disband their armed followers and promised pardon and a good reward to any bandit who delivered another bandit to him, dead or alive, the reward to be paid by the family or district of the captured man. When one bandit resisted this policy, Sixtus told his family to find him or suffer for it themselves. The duke of Urbino also laid a trap for the outlaws, and the pope was very pleased with this. (The source's gruesome details of the executions and of the trap are left out.)

No regard was paid to clerical rank or social standing. Offenders from the 'first families' were punished without pity or delay, and even a rebellious priest was hanged with the rest. After a time the whole area around the city was full of such grim warnings, and the wits of Rome joked that the heads displayed on the bridge of Sant'Angelo outnumbered the melons in the market stalls. People complained of the pope's savagery, but his ambassadors told him that in whatever part of his states they had traveled they had found peace and safety. This proud pope struck coins bearing the motto 'No one touches me'. In his piety he ordered very harsh penalties for moral offenses, including punishments of the young, and ordered that adulterers be put to death if caught; people were punished for crimes committed long before. A notice joked that even Saint Peter trembled lest Sixtus condemn him for cutting off Malchus' ear at the arrest of Christ.

Builder, reformer and scholar

In the midst of these frantic prosecutions he found time for government and reform. He gave up the confiscation of people's property begun under Gregory XIII. He reconciled the old rival families of Orsini and Colonna through a marriage between them. He chose the cardinals from eleven new 'congregations' and four old ones, and divided the business of the Vatican court among them. He ordered the clergy to obey the reforming decrees of the Council of Trent, and asked bishops to visit monasteries from time to time and set them in order. He revived the University of Rome and, to house the new books, had Domenico Fontana build a splendid new building for the Vatican Library. He personally supervised the Latin Bible, a work as important in its place as the English Bible produced in the time of King James.

Like his Renaissance predecessors, he had no respect for the remains of pagan art. He worked hard to demolish the Septizonium of Severus in order to use its columns in St Peter's, proposed leveling the tomb of Caecilia Metella, and threatened to pull down the Capitol if the statues of Jupiter, Apollo and Minerva were not removed. In the end he let Minerva stay, renaming her Rome and replacing her spear with a cross. He 'exorcised' the columns of Trajan and Marcus Aurelius by placing statues of the apostles Peter and Paul on top and renaming the columns accordingly. Then, to show that paganism was subdued by Christianity, he ordered Domenico Fontana to move to St Peter's Square the pyramid-shaped stone shaft that Caligula had brought from Heliopolis and Nero had placed in the Circus Maximus. The obelisk was granite, 25 meters high, and weighed more than 46 tons (the source's figure, which looks far too low). Master engineers such as Antonio da Sangallo and Michelangelo had said that moving it was beyond the powers of Renaissance engineering. Domenico and his brother Giovanni did it in a year (1585 to 1586). Huge machines lowered the monument and shifted it, and eight hundred workers, strengthened by religious rites, and one hundred and forty horses pulling forty-four thick ropes set it in its new place. After this Domenico became the hero of Rome. Sixtus had medals struck in memory of the work and sent official announcements to foreign governments. In place of the ball on the top he set a cross containing a fragment of the 'True Cross' on which Jesus died.

Sixtus believed that after the Renaissance, Christianity had regained its strength and power.

Written & researched by Dr. Shahin Siami

Related Articles