Baroque Art, Caravaggio and the Popes' Building in Rome

How the Baroque reshaped sculpture and painting, the Church's limits on art after Trent, Rome's painters, Caravaggio's dark realism and the popes' new palaces.

Baroque artCaravaggioRome

~9 min read · Updated Nov 20, 2026

The Baroque takes hold

These builders were tired of plain surfaces and huge masses. So they cut the cornices, divided the pediment decorations in two, and set a statue in every corner. The sculptors themselves were tired of perfect limbs and lifeless faces. They also did not want statues shown only from the front, so they gave them unprecedented poses and made viewers look from several angles. They also brought the effects of painting into sculpture, showing light and shade in stone, motion in the body, and thought and feeling in the face. Painters left perfect line, clear light and harmless calm to Perugino, Correggio and Raphael. Like Rubens they flooded the world with color; like Rembrandt they filled it with shadowy mystery; like Reni they stirred devotion; or like El Greco they disturbed it with anguish and ecstasy. Carpenters filled tables and chairs with ornament, and metalworkers turned metal into strange, whimsical shapes. In 1568, when the Jesuits commissioned Vignola to design their church of the Gesu in Rome, they required that it contain all the arts, in columns, statues, paintings and precious metals; it was not to display geometry but to inspire and spread faith.

Since Europe imitated Italy in art, the new decorative, emotional and expressionist style entered not only Spain, Flanders and Catholic France but also Protestant Germany, where it took cheerful forms. In literature the Baroque showed in the verbal play of Marino and Góngora, in the rich style of Shakespeare, in Marlowe's Doctor Faustus and in Goethe's Faust. Opera is music that has come under the Baroque. The new style did not win everywhere. Velázquez at his height was classical or realist, and Cervantes, after a romantic life, wrote Don Quixote with classical gravity and restraint. Corneille, Racine and Poussin were devotees of the classical style. Yet can we say that the followers of that style were always classical? Is anything stranger than the struggling Laocoon? History laughs at every attempt to bend it to theoretical ideals or logical lines, upsets our general conclusions and breaks all our rules. History too is strange.

The Church as patron

One strong factor always remained in Italian art: the Church was still its most active and creative patron. There were of course other patrons and influences. Ducal families and cultured cardinals built private palaces and used some pagan themes in decorating them; Cardinal Odoardo Farnese, for example, had Carracci paint the triumph of Bacchus and the reign of love for him. But the Council of Trent and the Catholic Reformation brought strictness to art, nude statues vanished from Italian art, and religious subjects were no longer used as a cover for sensuality. Only after the pleas of Roman artists did Pope Clement VIII refrain from having Michelangelo's Last Judgment painted over with the breeches (the book's note: Daniele da Volterra was commissioned to paint breeches over the bare figures, and so earned the nickname 'the breeches-maker') that Daniele da Volterra had been set to paint.

The Council of Trent had defended religious images against French Protestants and Puritans, but had warned that such images should lead to worship, not heat the blood. Since the Protestants had forbidden the veneration of Mary and the invocation of saints, Italian painters and sculptors after the Catholic Reformation sometimes showed the sufferings of the martyrs rather crudely and deliberately illustrated the story of Mary. The Church's concern to free art from Greek and Roman influence and to join religion and piety with Italy's political and economic defeats made this age the last stage of the Renaissance.

The arts of Rome

Rome was still regarded as the art capital of the world. The great age of Roman painting was over, and no Italian painter could rival Rubens or Rembrandt. But architecture in Rome was thriving, and for a generation Bernini was the most famous artist in Europe. Bologna had risen above other regions in painting, though its artists went to Rome to win final fame; Vasari went to the Vatican in 1572 to paint a series of frescoes in the Sala Regia. In Rome were seen painters whom a small circle still admired and respected, such as Taddeo and Federico Zuccaro, Girolamo Muziano, Francesco Salviati, Giovanni Lanfranco, Manfredi, Domenico Fetti and Andrea Sacchi.

Most of these painters are usually counted among the Mannerists, artists who followed the style of one or another master of the early Renaissance. This approach can be seen as the first stage of the Baroque.

Zuccaro raised his flag among four nations. In Florence he finished the paintings Vasari had begun in the dome of the cathedral; in the Vatican he painted in the Pauline Chapel; in Flanders he made a series of comic pictures; in England he painted famous portraits of Queen Elizabeth and Mary Stuart; in Spain he shared in decorating the Escorial; and on his return to Rome he founded the Academy of St Luke, whose organization led Reynolds in England to think of founding the Royal Academy. In his day Zuccaro was invited more than any other Italian painter, but the next generation preferred Pietro Berrettini da Cortona. With the special skill of Renaissance masters Pietro designed the Barberini and Pamphili palaces in Rome, and in the Pitti Palace in Florence painted frescoes full of strange Baroque shapes.

Caravaggio

The true master of Roman painting in this age was Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, who had a temper like Cellini's. Caravaggio was the son of a builder from Lombardy; after his schooling he went to Rome, joined in several quarrels, fought a fatal duel with a friend, was jailed, escaped, went to Malta and Syracuse, and died of sunstroke on the Sicilian shore at forty-four (1609; the book's age and year do not fit what is elsewhere known of him, and are kept here as given). Meanwhile he had brought about a half revolution in the state and technique of Italian painting. Caravaggio loved sharp contrasts of light and shade and used tricks such as lighting a scene from a hidden room, adorning figures with light and bringing them out of dark backgrounds. He began the rule of the 'tenebrists' in Italy, followed by Guercino, Ribera and Salvator Rosa. He had no regard for the imaginative sensibility that the Bologna painters followed, and shocked the people of his time with an almost animal realism.

When he put religious subjects on canvas, he painted the apostles and saints as rough dock workers. His Card Players (now in the Rothschild collection in Paris) made him internationally famous. His Musicians, showing singers and a handsome lute player, lay in dust for three centuries until it was found in an antique shop in northern England about 1935. It sold for 100 pounds, and the Metropolitan Museum in New York later bought it for 50,000 dollars (1952; the book's figures). The Church usually thought Caravaggio's religious pictures vulgar and lacking in loftiness, but today experts value them highly.

Rubens loved Caravaggio's Madonna in a Rose Garden (the book's title) so much that he collected 1,800 guilders from the artists of Antwerp to buy it and give it to the church of St Paul. The Supper at Emmaus (London) is not as deep as Rembrandt's work, but it is a powerful picture of peasant faces. The Death of the Virgin (Louvre), again with a rural scene, was one of the paintings that gave birth to the naturalist school in Italy and to realism in Spain and Holland. Caravaggio often stressed the melodrama of force and violence; but history, like orators, rarely makes a subject important without exaggeration. An age tired of subjects of sentiment shuddered at these strong harbor workers and then took them as a refreshing entry of forgotten men into art. Ribera took up Caravaggio's dark brush and matched him; Rembrandt imitated his chiaroscuro and perfected it; even nineteenth-century painters were strongly influenced by it.

The popes build

Meanwhile the Baroque appeared in architecture and reached its peak. One pope after another used the sweat and small coins of contented believers for the glory of Rome. Pius IV completed the loggia and other rooms of the Vatican. Gregory XIII built the Collegio Romano and began the Quirinal Palace, which in 1870 became the king's residence. Domenico Fontana, Sixtus V's favorite architect, designed the new Lateran Palace and also the Sistine chapel in the church of Santa Maria Maggiore, and inside that chapel he drew the plan of the tomb of Pope Pius V. Meanwhile cardinals and nobles raised new palaces such as the Borghese and Barberini, and villas such as the Borghese and Medici in Rome. In this period the pulling down of old buildings also went on: Paul V destroyed the Baths of Constantine, which had remained almost untouched since the first Christian emperor.

Written & researched by Dr. Shahin Siami

Related Articles