Guido Reni, Domenichino, Guercino and Naples Under Spain

The last Bolognese masters, the Church's need for sentiment, and Naples under Spanish viceroys: Evelyn's visit, Campanella and Masaniello's revolt.

Guido ReniNaplesMasaniello

~9 min read · Updated Nov 20, 2026

Guido Reni's art

A self-portrait of Guido, kept in the Capitoline Museum, shows him as a youth as lovely as a girl, with golden hair, delicate features and blue eyes. His masterpiece is the fresco Aurora on the ceiling of the Rospigliosi palace in Rome. The goddess of dawn flies through the air, followed by nimble horses drawing the tousle-haired Phoebus Apollo in his chariot, with dancing women of fair faces and forms, the Hours, around him, and a cherub who accompanies him gives this pagan ecstasy a Christian tint. Guido painted other mythological scenes too: The Rape of Helen in the Louvre, The Apples of the Hesperides in Naples, and the sensuous Venus and Cupid in Dresden. He also took subjects from the Old Testament, such as the famous Susanna and the Elders in the Uffizi. But he mostly settled for the old subjects favored by the public and the Church, such as the story of Jesus and his mother, which critics find full of 'thin' sentiment. His apostles were more interesting: St Matthew in the Vatican, a fine St James in the Brera, and in the Martyrdom of St Peter he imitated the rough realism of Caravaggio. Then he turned to sentiment again and painted the famous St Sebastian, showing the saint pierced by arrows. In all these pictures one sees the skill of an experienced artist. But when we compare their sweet, pious feeling with Raphael's Stanze or Michelangelo's Sistine ceiling, we are not moved by the coloring and the smoothness of line, and we wonder at the 'lack of soul' in Reni's art. He wrote, excusably, 'I like to give the picture I want to paint the kind of beauty that exists in heaven.' But when he claimed he could paint the eyes turned toward heaven in two hundred ways, he gave himself away.

Domenichino and Guercino

Domenichino, like Guido, tried to please pagans and worshippers alike, and since the two groups often looked alike, his work was useful. His nature was more complex than Guido's: modest, shy, devoted to music and to his wife. He too learned his art at Bologna and then followed the glitter of Rome. His success there made local rivals jealous, and they accused him of artistic theft. He went back to Bologna, but Gregory XV called him to the Vatican as chief architect and painter. With the same skill as the old masters of the Renaissance he built a villa for Ludovisi in Rome, now lost, and put up part of the Villa Aldobrandini at Frascati. Then he went to Naples and began a series of frescoes for the cathedral, and despite the difficulties that the rivalry of Neapolitan painters brought, he managed to finish almost all of it before his death. He was then (1641) sixty, and his art was at the height of its power. His greatest picture is The Last Communion of St Jerome, in the Vatican. It was on seeing this picture that Poussin judged Domenichino the greatest painter after Raphael. We value enthusiasm more than verdict. Ruskin held that Domenichino was noticeably incapable of doing anything good, great or right in any branch or manner. We admire neither the verdict nor the eloquence.

The last of Carracci's three famous pupils was pitifully nicknamed Guercino, 'the squinter,' because an event in his childhood left his eye turned, though his mother called him Giovanni Francesco Barbieri. Before studying under the Carracci he was a painter already, under the influence of Caravaggio's manly style, and so he became a link between Bologna and Rome. Like Guido he never married, lived almost like a monk, and showed the best side of the Catholic Reformation in his quiet, chaste life. Barbieri left beautiful pictures scattered from Rome to Chicago. He is thought the weakest and the best loved of the Bolognese school.

What the eclectic school gave the Church

The basic theory of the eclectic school, that a famous artist arises when he blends the best features of his predecessors' work, was certainly mistaken, for the genius is often the one who shows his own personality and finds new paths. But the merit of the Academy of the Incamminati lay in the tradition and order it set up, for without them genius might have run to extremes and produced oddities. The school's success was partly due to its readiness to meet the Church's needs. The reformed papacy and the growing Jesuit order needed fresh portrayals of the Passion and fresh stimuli to faith and devotion. The Bolognese painters stirred every feeling in the worshipper, and their pictures of the Virgin and Child and of Mary Magdalene are scattered across the Catholic world. Who can deny people's gratitude for these pictures, or claim that the Church was not the most skillful psychologist in history in obtaining them?

Naples under Spain

For some time the popes had held Forli, Ravenna, Rimini and Ancona. They took Urbino in 1626 and Pesaro in 1631 (the source's pairing; in other accounts Urbino came to the papacy in 1631). The Kingdom of Naples, governed from 1504 by a Spanish viceroy, covered, along the south toward the heel of the boot, Foggia, Bari and Brindisi, along the sole toward the toe, Taranto, Crotone and Reggio Calabria, from Scylla to Charybdis (in Sicily), and, along the west coast northward, as far as Capua. A population of three million, passionate in the hot climate and in poverty, toiled across that wide land to supply the means for the splendor of its capital. John Evelyn, who saw Naples in 1645, described it:

The officers of state, extremely greedy, filled their purses marvelously from the toil of the wretched people. ... For its extent the city is grander than other cities of Europe: its streets are very wide and paved, with underground channels for the sewage, so the streets are very pleasant and clean. ... There are more than three thousand churches and convents, and these buildings count as the best and handsomest in Italy. The people, wearing Spanish dress, imitate the Spaniards' dignity, enjoy riding, and the streets are full of well-dressed riders on horseback, in coaches and in sedan chairs. ... The women are generally good-looking but exceedingly sensual.

The people seemed cheerful, lively and devout, but beneath that bright surface, and under the supervision of the Inquisition, heresy and revolution were growing. The philosopher Telesio lived and died there (1588), and Bruno was born in Nola near Naples (1548). In 1598 Campanella took part in an uprising to make Calabria independent. The revolt came to nothing, and the poet-philosopher spent twenty-seven years in prison.

Masaniello's revolt

In 1647 one of those spectacular uprisings that from time to time interrupted the working of the land in Italy broke out in Naples. Tommaso Aniello, called Masaniello by the people, was a wandering fishmonger whose wife had been heavily fined for bringing in smuggled grain. When the Spanish governor of Naples, to strengthen the navy, put a tax on fruit, the fruit sellers and fruit growers refused to pay. Tommaso then called the people to revolt, and as he went to the viceroy's palace to obtain the repeal of the tax, a hundred thousand Italians followed him. The viceroy, in terror, granted their demand. Tommaso, who was no more than twenty-four, ruled Naples for ten days, and, drunk with the power of tyranny, had many of his opponents put to death, lowered the price of bread and ordered harsh punishments for those who broke his rules. (The source's figures and the cruelty of some of these orders are left out.) But his enemies rewrote history. It is said that Tommaso put on cloth of gold, turned his humble house into a palace that became his headquarters, and cruised the bay of Naples in a splendid boat. On 17 July a band of assassins in Spain's service murdered him. His followers recovered his body and buried it with a magnificent ceremony. The Neapolitan revolt, left without a leader, died away.

Under the rule of the archbishops and viceroys a gloomy kind of religious art was in fashion. In 1608 the Church spent 1,000,000 florins on building, in the cathedral, a shrine to hold two small vials containing the clotted blood of St Januarius, the patron of Naples. The people were told that the blood must liquefy and flow twice a year if Naples was to prosper and be safe from Vesuvius, the volcano.

Painting in Naples was for a time controlled by three jealous artists, Corenzio, Caracciolo and Ribera, who declared that Neapolitan painting must be done by themselves or their friends. They threatened Annibale Carracci so much that he fled to Rome, and some time later, as a result of a journey... (the source's sentence breaks off here and continues in the next section of the text).

Written & researched by Dr. Shahin Siami

Related Articles