Monteverdi, the First Operas and Italian Letters

How opera grew from church drama, masques and the Florentine circle, Monteverdi's rise, and the academies, historians and pastoral plays of Italian letters.

MonteverdiOperaItalian literature

~8 min read · Updated Nov 20, 2026

The roots of opera

Several strands of music went into the making of opera. Some medieval religious plays already used song and music, and in the settings written for the sufferings of Christ the Church encouraged the new form. At late medieval courts recitatives were heard with music. Renaissance scholars held that the Greeks sang parts of their tragedies or played tunes during them. At the court of Mantua, in a year the book gives as 1742 (clearly a slip), Angelo Poliziano blended music and drama in a play called Favola d'Orfeo, and from then on the sad tale found its way into opera. The masques that were fashionable at sixteenth-century courts opened another road: the ballet, the costly scenery and the rich costumes of modern opera may well descend from the dances, pageants and splendid dress of the Renaissance masque.

In the late sixteenth century a group of music and literature lovers who met at the house of Giovanni Bardi in Florence set out to revive the Greek drama with music. They wanted to free the voice from tangled, heavy part-writing and from the unintelligible words of madrigals, and to bring back what they believed was the style of ancient tragedy. One member, Vincenzo Galilei, father of the famous astronomer, set parts of Dante's Inferno to lament-like music. Two others, the poet Ottavio Rinuccini and the singer Jacopo Peri, prepared the words and the music of the first opera in the world, Dafne, which was staged in 1597 at the house of Jacopo Corsi. It pleased so much that Rinuccini was asked to write verses for the wedding of Henry IV and Marie de' Medici in Florence (6 October 1600), and Peri and Caccini were asked to compose the music. The opera performed there, Euridice, is the oldest opera we possess. Peri apologized for its flaws, caused by haste, but hoped he had opened the way for more gifted men to win the glory that he had missed.

Monteverdi

That glory went to one of the great figures in the history of music, Claudio Monteverdi, who mastered the violin in his native Cremona. At twenty-two (1589) he became one of the musicians of the Duke of Mantua, and at thirty-five head of the singers. Critics attacked his five books of love madrigals for harsh sounds, 'sensual modulations', 'illegal' passage from one mode to another, broken rules of counterpoint and awkward joining of voices. Giovanni Artusi, in a book on the defects of modern music, complained that the new composers seemed pleased when they could make the best pieces by joining wholly unlike elements into a mass of unpleasant sounds. Monteverdi went on to the new kind he had heard in Florence, and at Mantua composed his first opera, Orfeo (1607), for an orchestra of thirty-six instruments. Its music and action were far better than Peri's Euridice. His second opera, Arianna (1608), was more exciting and its tunes more pleasing, so that all Italy began to sing Ariadne's lament, 'Let me die'.

As Shakespeare opened a new stage in the theater, Monteverdi advanced opera greatly by enlarging and rearranging the orchestra, giving each character a tune of his own, writing overtures for his operas, improving recitatives and melodies, and building a close, complex unity of music and drama. In 1612 he went to Venice as choirmaster of St Mark's. He wrote more pieces there, but turned a declining art toward declamation and oratory, so that critics charged him with making music serve drama (just as Bernini was charged with making music serve sculpture). In 1637 Venice opened the first public opera house, where Monteverdi's Adone (the book's title for it) ran from 1639 to 1640, and Arianna sometimes appeared in another theater. When he composed his last opera, the book's 'Coronation of the Pope' (the title is garbled; the work is evidently The Coronation of Poppea, 1642), Italians were glad that at seventy-five he was still in full power (as Verdi was at seventy-four when he wrote Otello). The next year Monteverdi died, having inspired and made young again the world of music by his revolution.

Italian letters after the Renaissance

It is astonishing that even in this so-called age of decline Italy bred geniuses in every field. For abundance and fire in literature it counts as a fertile age, and only lack of time, space and information keeps us from doing it justice.

The Italian mastery naturally declined after the Renaissance, because Greece and Rome could not be rediscovered forever. From then on literature was kept up by literary academies, which by their structure had to be conservative. Almost every Italian town had one, cultivating letters and approving one another's verses. The Crusca Academy, founded in Florence in 1572, produced a dictionary about 1612, before the French Academy, and tried to bring literary style and taste under regular rules. In this age Italian historians were the best. We have mentioned Sarpi's lively History of the Council of Trent. Cardinal Guido Bentivoglio wrote a very moving and sympathetic account of the Dutch revolt. He might have written more, but death took him in a conclave just when he seemed likely to be elected pope; Nicius Erythraeus claimed that a fellow cardinal's snoring in the next cell kept him awake eleven nights in a row, and so killed him. Cardinal Cesare Baronius wrote a full church history in twelve volumes, to which scholars later added twenty-six more. Ranke thought it lacked charm, but Gibbon found it useful, and the cardinal tried honorably to judge fairly: 'Whoever carefully corrects my mistakes I shall love dearly.' Isaac Casaubon set out to do this, but after writing an introduction of eight hundred pages he gave up the plan.

While the theater declined, playwriting prospered. Few plays worth naming were written, but a great many were staged, with such beautiful and skilled scenery that Inigo Jones was amazed. All over Europe people wanted Italian actors. While in England boys played women's parts, in Italy women appeared on stage and actresses were respected. Tasso wrote a sonnet for Isabella Andreini, who was not only a beautiful actress but a fair poet and a kind wife.

Two plays of this period stand out, partly because they created a new style, the pastoral drama. Tasso encouraged it with Aminta, and Guarini gave a classic model in Il Pastor Fido. Tasso said of him: 'If he had not read Aminta, he could not have written better.' Cardinal Bellarmine criticized Guarini's play for its sensuality, saying it did more harm to Christianity than the heresies of Luther and Calvin; yet after long search we find no scene bolder than the one in which the fair Corisca offers her breast to the heedless Silvio, a huntsman who has 'all his mind on the chase' and takes no notice of the nymphs. Apart from Silvio, the play, like almost all the verse of the age, has an amorous tone and gives life to love. The action takes place in an Arcadia-like plain, in the golden age when milk was the only food and love was safe from every criticism and chain. Partly through reading Aminta, Il Pastor Fido, Montemayor's Diana, Sidney's Arcadia and Fletcher's Faithful Shepherdess, half of the literate people of Europe were invited out to the fields. Crescimbeni lists 661 Italian poets of the sixteenth century who sounded rhymes in imitation of Petrarch. Campanella and Bruno threw away some of the best sonnets of the time, on the ground that they were only sparks of the fire of philosophy. Alessandro Tassoni attacked the sonneteers and the worshippers of Petrarch, Marino and Tasso in one of the best-known Italian works, La Secchia rapita ('The Stolen Bucket'). Because its victim was a powerful man, no one dared print it, yet the public wanted it so much that scribes made good money copying and selling it (at a price the book puts at 120 present-day dollars a copy; dropped here as a conversion). In the end it was printed in France and smuggled into Italy. What charmed Italians was not the satire and mockery but the pure verse that stopped their laughter, as when the tale of Endymion appears in the most delicate way almost beside a story told of a senator who sat on the privy and flew up to heaven.

Written & researched by Dr. Shahin Siami

Related Articles