Ribera of Naples, Rome of the Popes and Pius V

Ribera's career and rivalries in Naples, then Rome around 1600: its noble families, papal nepotism and the austere reforming pope Pius V.

RiberaRomePius V

~9 min read · Updated Nov 20, 2026

The end of Annibale Carracci and the flight of other painters

The sentence left open in the previous post closes quickly. After a feverish journey under the southern sun, Annibale Carracci, the great painter of the Farnese gallery, died (the source says only 'in this city', so the place is unclear; most likely Rome). Guido Reni fared no better in Naples. When he came to decorate the Treasury chapel he received a warning to leave or be killed, and he fled before beginning the work. Two of his assistants, who refused to go, were put on a ship and nobody heard of them again. Domenichino also came and finished four frescoes of that chapel, although his work was repeatedly spoiled; then, under the threats of Ribera, he left. Later the viceroy promised him protection and he returned, but he died soon after in Naples, in circumstances that some thought suspicious.

Ribera, the master of Neapolitan painting

Despite his intrigues, Jusepe de Ribera is counted the greatest painter of Italy in this period. Because he was born at Xativa near Valencia, the Spaniards claimed him as theirs, and the Italians called him 'Spagnoletto', the little Spaniard. He studied for a time under Francisco Ribalta, but in early youth he set out for Rome. There he lived in poverty, copying frescoes and gathering crumbs, until an art-loving cardinal took him into his palace and gave him a room, food, paints and clothes. Ribera copied Raphael in the Vatican and the Carracci in the Farnese palace; then, feeling that comfort had cooled his feeling, he went to Parma and Modena to study Correggio. Back in Rome he quarreled with Domenichino, moved to Naples, and fell under the influence of Caravaggio, whose realism strengthened his belief in copying nature, a belief he may have taken from Ribalta. A rich dealer in pictures took a liking to him and offered him his beautiful daughter. Poor Ribera took the offer for a joke, but when it was repeated he consented to the marriage and was happy.

Soon he painted his picture of St Bartholomew's martyrdom, so lifelike that when it was shown crowds came, more eager to look at blood than at art. The viceroy, the very man who had plotted against Venice, wanted to see the painter and the picture; delighted, he told Ribera to take charge of all the decoration of his palace. The insatiable Spaniard drove his rivals from the field, until the commission for the Treasury chapel frescoes was given to Giovanni Lanfranco. Ribera himself made the altarpiece, which showed the 'fireproof' statue of St Januarius coming unharmed out of a blazing furnace.

From then on Ribera was the unchallenged master of Neapolitan art. He seemed able at will to rival Raphael and Correggio in delicacy, to avoid the sentimentality of Guido Reni or Murillo, and to be more realistic than Caravaggio through his power of perception and the depth of his color. We should mention his Pieta and Lamentation in the church and monastery of San Martino, of which a critic said that beside these 'all similar pictures of that time look like stage plays', so grand is their picture of grief. Among his ancient subjects, the Archimedes in the Prado looks exactly like one of the wrinkled old Sicilian men one can still find in Syracuse. Ribera stepped outside the circle of the Bible and history into the streets, and by painting real scenes of people's lives he added variety to his art; in The Clubfoot (the Louvre) he gave Velazquez and Murillo a model.

His faults are quickly seen: an exaggerated love of cruelty, a taste for wrinkles and veins, and a thirst for blood. Byron wrote that the little Spaniard colored his brush with the blood of all the saints. His dark colors and his gloomy subjects fill us with dread and sadness, but in Naples, shaped by Spanish thought, his gloomy style was readily accepted. New churches and monasteries competed to employ him, and among his eager customers were Philip IV and the viceroys of Naples. His pictures and drawings were scattered through Spain more than Velazquez's, who twice came to Italy to see him. His house was among the finest in Naples, and his two daughters were perfect examples of dark-haired beauty. One of them was led astray by another Don Juan, a natural son of Philip IV, who took her to Sicily and, when he tired of her, left her in a convent in Palermo. Ribera was nearly crushed by grief and shame and found comfort in painting pictures of the Virgin that recalled the face of his lost Maria Rosa. Four years after his daughter's misfortune, he died (1652).

Rome and the popes

The capital of the Papal States and center of the Catholic world was then a city of second rank. The Papal States covered Rome, Ostia, Viterbo, Terni, Spoleto, Foligno, Assisi, Perugia, Gubbio, Urbino, Loreto, Ancona, Pesaro, Rimini, Forli, Ravenna, Bologna and Ferrara, with their surroundings. Rome had 45,000 people in 1558 (according to the book), and under Pope Sixtus V (1590) the number reached 100,000. Montaigne, who came in 1580, thought it more extensive than Paris but its houses only a third as many. Before Sixtus V, bandits and prostitutes made up an important part of the population, and many nobles kept a permanent staff of ruffians. Poverty was general but not severe, softened by papal charity, church ceremonies and vows.

The old aristocratic families, the Orsini, Colonna, Savelli, Gaetani and Chigi, had fallen in wealth and power but still clung to their claims and pride. The newer families, the Aldobrandini, Barberini, Borghese, Farnese and Rospigliosi, came first in wealth and importance because they were usually connected with popes. Popes favored their kin: the Aldobrandini profited from the election of Clement VIII, the Ludovisi from Gregory XV, the Barberini from Urban VIII and the Borghese from Paul V. Paul's nephew Cardinal Scipione Borghese, who enjoyed the income of several churches and 150,000 scudi a year (the book's figure), planned the Villa Borghese, built the Casino Borghese (1615), assembled its priceless collections, and was made almost immortal by the marble bust his protege Bernini carved of him. Many cardinals spent their fortunes on literature and art.

Pius V, the austere pope

Though Germany, Holland, England and Scandinavia had left the authority of Rome through the Reformation, the coming of several strong popes strengthened the Church. The Council of Trent confirmed the supremacy of the popes over councils, and the young and vigorous Jesuit order was devoted to them. In 1561 (the source's date; Pius V's election is commonly placed in 1566) Michele Ghislieri, formerly a Dominican friar and a high officer of the Inquisition, became pope at sixty-two as Pius V. The holiness of his own life seemed to him quite consistent with severity toward heresy. He took from the Catholics of Bohemia the right they once had to receive wine as well as bread at Mass; he excommunicated Queen Elizabeth of England and forbade her Catholic subjects to obey her; he urged Charles IX of France and Catherine de Medici to keep up the war against French Protestants, and he praised Alva's severe measures in the Netherlands. Yet, old and worn as he was, he fitted out ships and with them helped defeat the Ottoman Turks at Lepanto. He never softened a sentence and urged the Inquisition to enforce its laws and penalties.

He was equally strict in Church reform: he removed bishops who would not live in their sees, made monks and nuns live fully apart from the world, and sought out and punished every abuse in the Church. When discharged and surplus officials of the Vatican court complained that they would starve, he answered that it was better to starve than to have their souls fall into eternal torment. Appointments were made on merit, and the pope gave no thought to the families of those he chose. He himself worked with great care, sat for hours as a judge, slept no more than five hours, and with his simple, ascetic life gave the clergy a lesson; he often fasted and wore a rough woolen monk's habit under his papal robe. These austerities wore him out, so that at sixty-eight he looked ten years older, thin and frail, with sunken eyes and white hair; though he could hardly walk, he insisted on making the pilgrimage to the seven churches of Rome on foot. After a month of suffering he died in the habit of St Dominic. A Protestant historian wrote: 'The Catholic world owes more to Pius V than to other popes, for though he persecuted heretics without mercy, his belief in the need for reform and his unshaken resolve to carry it out enabled the Church to regain much of the respect it had lost.' He was canonized in 1712.

Written & researched by Dr. Shahin Siami

Related Articles